By Jane Adler
Special to the Tribune
Even as the U.S.
Supreme Court considers a case on whether people with disabilities
can sue states for failing to make public buildings accessible,
the overall trend toward increased accessibility is gradually
gaining acceptance among home builders.
And that's good
news for seniors.
Not too surprisingly,
developers that build houses just for seniors are leading
the way on accessibility. These projects often include elder-friendly
features such as no-step entries, single-level designs, big
bathrooms and wide hallways. After all, many older people
have trouble with stairs. Seniors might also eventually need
a walker or wheelchair that requires extra room to maneuver.
"Senior housing
[builders] are comfortable with the idea" of accessibility,
said Louis Tenenbaum, a consultant in Potomac, Md., who works
with builders on accessibility issues.
Take, for example,
the new Skokie Gardens Condominiums project under way in Skokie
at 8828 Niles Center Rd. Each of the building's 70 units has
wide hallways and doorways. There is no step down to the outside
balconies.
"We asked the
architect to design the building so it is more easily accessible,"
said Abdul Matin, president at Skokie-based Fortune Group
LLC, the building's developer. "Older people have requirements,
and you have to keep that in mind." The building isn't
only for seniors, Matin adds, but he expects most of the buyers
to be older people from the area.
Accessibility features
were planned into the duplex and fourplex units at the new
Chatham Grove development in Aurora. The project, at 1620
S. Farnsworth Ave., will have 99 units. Residents must be
at least 55 years old.
Among features that
make the units more accessible: Hallways are 48 inches wide,
rather than the standard 42 inches; interior doors are 3 feet
wide; doorknobs were scrapped for levers; and there are no
front stoops with stairs.
"This is the
first community we have built that has these kinds of features
in every unit," said Jean Neumann, chief marketing officer
at Neumann Homes Inc., Warrenville. "We do not use these
features in our other projects."
Builders face a
maze of regulations and laws on accessibility. Federal law
says the common areas of a building must be accessible. Other
federal rules as well as state and local laws dictate accessibility
requirements for individual units. But the rules generally
don't apply to townhouses or single-family homes, though that's
changing too.
So, seniors looking
for a place with accessible-type features encounter a hodge-podge
of arrangements. Some buildings have a certain percentage
of accessible units. Many buildings have units that are called
adaptable, meaning they can be converted into accessible units.
For example, an adaptable unit might have a under-sink cabinet
that can be removed easily to make space for a wheelchair.
All of the units
at Skokie Gardens are adaptable, but 20 percent of the units
are accessible. These units will have low countertops and
room for wheelchairs under sinks.
Chicago developer
Belgravia Group Ltd. is making some of its new town homes
adaptable. At its Kensington Park project at 18th Street and
Indiana Avenue, four of the 45 units are being built with
space where an elevator can be added. "If you plan ahead,
it's not that hard to do," said Belgravia President Alan
D. Lev.
Lev was on the committee
that helped draft a new Chicago ordinance that requires single-family
homes and townhouses in big planned developments to build
10 percent of their units adaptable. The ordinance, which
will take effect July 1, also requires 10 percent of the units
to be "visitable," which generally means they will
have no-step entries and a ground-floor bathroom.
A number of cities
are adopting visitability codes, though the requirements of
local laws vary. Naperville has one of the few laws in the
nation that requires visitability features in all new single-family
homes. Also, U.S. Rep. Jan Shakowsky (D-Ill.) has introduced
federal legislation, the Inclusive Home Design Act, that would
require homes built with government money to have accessible
features.
Developer Lev thinks
it's smart business to make all kinds of homes more accessible.
"It's the wave of the future," he said. "I
think there's a market for my town homes among empty-nesters,
someone who wants to buy a house and stay there but who may
not be able to do the stairs some day."
But builders disagree
on whether good accessible designs make for good marketing.
They say home buyers, even older ones, don't want to be reminded
that they may some day need a wheelchair or walker.
"Builders are
scratching their heads wondering how they can tell buyers
they might become frail and need an accessible house,"
consultant Tenenbaum said.
Developer Matin
soft pedals accessibility features to buyers. If he markets
the units as accessible, he thinks younger buyers might be
scared away. Matin says many seniors don't particularly like
being told the units are handicap-accessible or even easily
adapted for someone with physical limitations.
"Other than
a few differences in the cabinets, no one would notice a difference
in the accessible units," he said. "But [buyers]
say they want a normal unit. They do not want to be stigmatized."
|